Nicotine Science and Policy
By Harry Shapiro Sept. 11, 2025
Harry’s blog 129: Prohibition: the lessons we never learn
Australia’s unnecessary nicotine war lights up,
As reported on the website of ALIVE, the Australian vaping advocacy movement, “Australia's ongoing battle against tobacco has led to some of the strictest regulations in the world, particularly concerning vaping and cigarette pricing. While the government has framed these policies as necessary for public health, the unintended consequences have sparked a growing crisis.”
April 07, 2026 by substack.com
Is there "third hand vaping"? Part I
Growing discussion is emerging around the concept of “third-hand exposure” in relation to vaping, drawing parallels with the well-established phenomenon of third-hand smoke. The analysis explores whether residues from exhaled e-cigarette aerosol can persist on surfaces and undergo chemical transformations over time. While such processes are theoretically possible in indoor environments, the complexity of aerosol behaviour and surface interactions makes their real-world significance difficult to assess. The discussion highlights that much of the existing evidence is based on laboratory models rather than everyday conditions. At the centre of the debate is whether these mechanisms translate into meaningful exposure risks, particularly compared to what is already known about tobacco smoke.
April 07, 2026 by substack.com
Is there "third hand vaping"? Part II
Further analysis argues that under normal conditions, the concept of “third-hand vaping” lacks prac…
April 07, 2026 by eureporter.co
Commission evaluation of the EU tobacco control framework highlights progress and emerging public health challenges
The European Commission has published a comprehensive evaluation of the EU’s tobacco control framework, highlighting significant progress in reducing smoking rates and tobacco-related harm across the bloc. Since 2012, smoking prevalence has declined notably, reflecting the impact of regulations on product standards, advertising, and public health measures. At the same time, the report identifies new and evolving challenges linked to the rapid growth of alternative nicotine products, particularly among younger populations. While existing legislation has improved both public health outcomes and the functioning of the internal market, gaps remain in addressing newer product categories and regulatory inconsistencies across member states. The findings are expected to inform upcoming revisions of EU tobacco policy, as policymakers seek to balance continued progress with emerging risks in a changing nicotine landscape.
April 07, 2026 by clivebates.com
How to eliminate the tobacco industry
Growing debate is emerging around the idea of a “tobacco endgame”, with some advocates calling for the complete elimination of the tobacco industry. However, this perspective is being challenged by arguments that such an approach is unrealistic and may even produce unintended consequences, including the expansion of illicit markets. The discussion suggests that efforts to suppress the industry through restrictive regulation can inadvertently reinforce the dominance of large incumbents or drive consumers towards illegal supply chains. Instead, a more pragmatic approach is proposed: aligning the incentives of tobacco companies with public health goals to accelerate the transition away from smoking towards lower-risk alternatives. At its core, the argument reframes the objective—not as eliminating the industry or nicotine altogether, but as achieving a rapid and sustained decline in smoking-related harm.
April 07, 2026 by adebisiyusuff.com
The Evidence Doesn’t Say That: On the New E-Cigarette Carcinogenicity Review
Growing debate is emerging around a recent qualitative review assessing the carcinogenic potential of e-cigarettes, with particular attention to how evidence is interpreted and communicated. The analysis brings together findings from laboratory studies, biomarkers, and animal research, suggesting possible biological mechanisms—such as DNA damage, oxidative stress, and inflammation—that could be linked to cancer development. At the same time, the discussion highlights important limitations, including the lack of long-term epidemiological data and the difficulty of translating experimental findings into real-world risk. While some evidence points to exposure to potentially carcinogenic compounds, the overall level of risk remains uncertain and continues to be debated within the scientific community. The issue reflects a broader challenge in public health: how to interpret emerging, and sometimes conflicting, evidence on newer nicotine products while balancing precaution with comparative risk assessment against smoking.
April 07, 2026 by dcjournal.com
Youth Tobacco Numbers Show a Public Health Win. So Why Is the FDA Silent?
Growing debate is emerging over how regulators communicate progress in reducing youth tobacco use in the United States. Newly released federal data show significant declines across multiple categories, including vaping, cigarette smoking, and nicotine pouch use among young people. Despite these trends being widely described as a public health success, critics argue that the lack of public response from the Food and Drug Administration raises questions about transparency and consistency. Some commentators suggest that declining youth usage challenges earlier narratives of a widespread “youth vaping epidemic,” prompting calls for a reassessment of current regulatory approaches. At the same time, the discussion highlights broader tensions between youth protection policies and the role of lower-risk nicotine alternatives for adult smokers.
14.10% of the adult population are current smokers. There are approximately 39.8 million current smokers in United States 17.10% of men are current smokers but only 11.10% of women.
SOURCE: GSTHR
Blogs
Harry’s blog 129: Prohibition: the lessons we never learn
Australia’s unnecessary nicotine war lights up,
As reported on the website of ALIVE, the Australian vaping advocacy movement, “Australia's ongoing battle against tobacco has led to some of the strictest regulations in the world, particularly concerning vaping and cigarette pricing. While the government has framed these policies as necessary for public health, the unintended consequences have sparked a growing crisis.”
Harry’s blog 128: Behind the smoke and mirrors: the continuing challenge of tobacco harm reduction.
“If you assume that there is no hope, you guarantee there will be no hope”. Noam Chomsky
I recently returned from the 12th annual Global Forum on Nicotine (GFN) conference in Warsaw. My first visit was 2015 when I had just entered the tobacco harm reduction (THR) space after over thirty years spent with UK NGOs advocating for drug and HIV harm reduction – a space I still inhabit.
Harry’s blog 127: The truth is still out there.
A free self-guided introduction to tobacco harm reduction from K•A•C aims to raise awareness of the approach among a wider community of policymakers, researchers, health professionals – and adult smokers.