Evidence, not fear, should guide the FDA’s vaping policies
August 18, 2025 by reason.org
Evidence, not fear, should guide the FDA’s vaping policies
FDA Commissioner Makary emphasized stakeholder consensus and evidence-based decisions on policy issues in a podcast, raising concerns about a "child vaping epidemic" but overlooking adult smokers' needs. Makary should prioritize alternatives for adult smokers, as evidence supports e-cigarettes as a less harmful option than combustible cigarettes. Emphasizing public education to correct misconceptions and authorizing a broader range of appealing alternatives could lead to better health outcomes. Restrictive measures, such as flavor bans, risk driving consumers to the unregulated market and increasing tobacco sales. To improve public health, FDA policies should align with evidence-based approaches and address adult smokers' needs to reduce illicit products and promote safer choices.
