Commentary

0
0
0
s2smodern

 Clive Bates | 23 July 2013

I was trying to pen some wonkish words about the state of play on the tobacco products directive now the European Parliament scrutiny debate,Council General Approach and Commission proposals are all done. But then I thought:no, why dignify all this? In a crowded field, it’s possibly the worst legislative mess I have ever seen – a gargantuan dog’s breakfast, a gluttonous feast of uncooked ideas unfit for human consumption.

0
0
0
s2smodern

 Clive Bates | 10 July 2013

What do the supporters of medicines regulation for e-cigs say, and why are they wrong?

 

0
0
0
s2smodern

 Clive Bates | 19 June 2013

To coincide with World No Tobacco Day 2013 (theme: are you being manipulated?), I attended a workshop in the European Parliament: Do tobacco control measures reduce tobacco use: evidence from research and practice . Frankly, it was quite irksome at times. I finally felt obliged to tackle one of the speakers: here’s what happened…

0
0
0
s2smodern

 Clive Bates | 19 June 2013

A public health academic is forceful and direct with the misguided opponents and over-zealous regulators of e-cigarettes. He describes the presentation of World Health Organisation’s Roberto Bertollini to a European Parliament workshop as ‘appalling’. This is a measured, compassionate, but quietly angry and exasperated interview by one of Europe’s leading experts on e-cigarettes, Professor Jean-François Etter.I hope everyone involved with the e-cigarette policy debate will take 5 minutes to view this – it says pretty well all that needs to be said. Some quotes I’ve drawn out:

 

0
0
0
s2smodern

 Clive Bates | 19 June 2013

So the MHRA will regulate e-cigarettes as though they are medicines – press release . 10 reasons why is this a bad idea.

 

0
0
0
s2smodern

 Clive Bates | 9 June 2013

Time to discuss the ‘gateway effect’… the idea that e-cigarettes or snus (a form of low risk smokeless tobacco) might be a cause of children taking up high risk cigarette smoking that would not otherwise happen. There’s virtually nothing in this theory – it is largely a campaigning tactic. But you hear much less about the genuine beneficial gateway effects that lead kids away from smoking. As my friend David Sweanor puts it:

beware the unintended consequences of our fear of unintended consequences

David Sweanor

0
0
0
s2smodern

 Clive Bates | 23 May 2013

When the UK Medicines Regulator (MHRA) consulted in 2010 on whether e-cigarettes should be regulated as medicines, it gave three options: I summarise the first two and quote the third:
Option 1 . Regulate as medicines and withdraw unlicensed products in 21 days
Option 2 . Regulate as medicines and withdraw unlicensed products in a year (June 2011)
Option 3 . “ Do nothing and allow these unregulated products containing nicotine that have not been assessed for safety, quality and efficacy to remain on the market .” [emphasis mine]

0
0
0
s2smodern

 Gerry Stimson | 23 May 2013

In a letter to MEPs on the EU Parliament ENVI Committee, regarding the proposed regulation of electronic cigarettes in the draft Tobacco Products Directive, Professor Gerry Stimson makes the case for ‘twin-track’ regulation

April 22, 2013

Dear Member,

I am writing to you concerning the draft Tobacco Products Directive and in particular Article 18 which seeks to regulate nicotine containing products (NCP) - including electronic cigarettes - as medicinal products.